Shawnee State University
Academics Future Students Current Students Faculty/Staff Alumni/Friends Parents

  Clark Memorial Library > Clark Memorial Library Collection Development Policy

Clark Memorial Library's Collection Development Policy


1) enables selectors of Clark Memorial Library materials to work with greater consistency toward defined goals, thus shaping a stronger collection while using funds more wisely; 2) informs library staff, users, administrators, trustees, and others about the scope and nature of the collection and the plan for continuing development of resources; and 3) provides information which will assist in budgetary allocation processes.

Departmental Selection Policies specify parameters of collection development and suggest useful bibliographic resources per each unit funded with a library allocation.  


Preface

The purpose of this instrument is threefold:

1) to enable selectors of Clark Memorial Library materials to work with greater consistency toward defined goals, thus shaping a stronger collection while using funds more wisely.
2) to inform library staff, users, administrators, trustees, and others about the scope and nature of the collection and the plan for continuing development of resources.

3) to provide information which will assist in budgetary allocation processes.

This policy conforms to the prescriptions suggested in Guide for Written Collection Policy Statements, from the Subcommittee on Guidelines for Collection Development, Collection Management and Development Committee, Resources Section, Resources and Technical Services Division, American Library Association edited by Bonita Bryant, (Chicago: ALA, 1989) and Collection Development Policies for College Libraries: CLIP Note # 11, from the College Library Information Packet Committee, College Libraries Section, Association of College and Research Libraries, compiled by Theresa Taborsky and Patricia Lenkowski, (Chicago: ALA, 1989.)


I. Introduction/Goals/Mission

University Description

Shawnee State University is unique among Ohio's public institutions of higher education in that it is the only state-supported university dedicated solely to undergraduate education. Programming at the university is student-centered, emphasizes the interests of Appalachians, and focuses on undergraduate learning. Recognizing that the "people of South Central Ohio view Shawnee State University as an agent for change and economic growth" (A View of the Future: Guidelines for Strategic Planning at Shawnee State University, p. 3), the University interacts within the economic, civic, and cultural communities of South Central Ohio to support, strengthen, broaden, and infuse local initiatives. (1997-99 Shawnee State University Catalog, p. 3-8, and A View of the Future: Guidelines for Strategic Planning at Shawnee State University, September 2, 1997, p. 3-4)

Although SSU is a young institution, college classes in Portsmouth have been ongoing for many years. From the 1940's through the 1970's, Portsmouth was home to an Ohio University branch campus; in 1975 the O.U. branch merged with Scioto Technical College to form Shawnee State General and Technical College. Then in 1977 that institution was renamed Shawnee State Community College. Finally, in 1986 Shawnee State University was created by an act of the Legislature of the State of Ohio.

Since its foundation as a state university, Shawnee State faculty and staff have worked determinedly not only to expand the physical plant of the campus but also to extend and improve course offerings, programs, and support services for students. Among the goals stated in the 1997-99 Catalog, the University includes offering "baccalaureate and associate degrees in the traditional academic fields, innovative interdisciplinary programs, and technical and career-oriented programs" which meet "continuing education and training needs of business and industry." Additionally, the university intends to participate as "a willing partner in cooperative ventures with educational institutions and organizations that assist in developing the economic, educational, and cultural base of South Central Ohio." (1997-99 Shawnee State University Catalog, p. 6-7.)

In the Vision Statements of the 1997-99 Catalog, the University articulates these goals:

  • SSU "will become...THE Regional State University for South Central Ohio with visibility on a statewide and national level in select academic areas;"
  • "Shawnee State University will provide a comprehensive higher educational experience for its students;"
  • SSU "will establish and maintain academic programs supportive of a focused academic mission founded primarily on technological, career oriented, and professional programs." (1997-99 Shawnee State University Catalog, p. 6-7.)

Shawnee State University Mission Statement

Shawnee State University-the regional state university for Southern Ohio-prepares students for the changing needs of business, industry, education, and society through its diversified degree programs. Recognizing the importance of knowledge, values, and cultural enrichment, Shawnee State University is committed to providing higher education that fosters competence in oral and written communication, scientific and quantitative reasoning, and critical analysis/logical thinking. To enrich the lives of the community, the University provides opportunities for continuing personal and professional development, intellectual discovery, and appreciation for the creative and performing arts. 

(http://www.shawnee.edu/off/pres/mission.html)

Library Description

In the 1993 vision statement "A View of the Future: Guidelines for Strategic Planning at Shawnee State University," a sub-goal specified that the University will "assure continuing support for development of library resources commensurate with existing programs and in anticipation of new programs."

The Clark Memorial Library staff envisions the Library as existing to provide the materials and staff resources to meet the information needs of faculty, students, and staff and to support the instruction, research, service, and public outreach concerns of the University. The Library's mission statement follows:

The mission of Clark Memorial Library is to “bring people and information together” to foster excellence in learning, teaching, and research. To accomplish this mission we are committed to:
  • offering a basic collection of electronic and hard copy information resources that supports Shawnee State  University’s curriculum and special interests
  • teaching users to efficiently and effectively access, evaluate, and utilize information resources
  • facilitating reference services that assist users in locating appropriate materials
  • making available the technology needed to access  and utilize Clark Memorial Library and OhioLINK  resources
  • providing a comfortable, accommodating environment for study and research, intellectual growth, and personal development.

(http://www.shawnee.edu/off/cml/clarklibinfo/dir.html)

The building which currently houses the Library, constructed at a cost of $6.7 million and fitted with an additional $1 million worth of new interior furnishings, opened to the public in June 1991. However, the acquisition of Library materials had been begun prior to the construction of Massie Hall (the building which housed the Ohio University-Portsmouth branch), and the Library was housed on the first floor of Massie Hall from its opening in 1967 until the new SSU Library was completed in 1991.

Following the designation of Shawnee as a state university, the Library was granted a special funding supplement of $1,100,000 which resulted in an increase of the materials collection from 68,000 volumes in 1988 to 93,000 in 1991. Additional projects such as the automation of the catalog and the creation of an interactive circulation system, the development of a video collection, and the creation of a Curriculum Materials Center to support the teacher education program were also begun during this period. In 1989 Shawnee State was designated a selective government depository and currently receives about 11% of all materials available through the government depository program.

In order to ensure continuing accreditation of the university, the Library will strive to meet the standards articulated by the Association of College and Research Libraries in the documents such as "Standards for Libraries in Higher Education" and in "Guidelines for University Library Services to Undergraduate Students."


II. Intellectual Freedom Statement

The Clark Memorial Library supports intellectual freedom, freedom of inquiry, freedom of expression, and the free exchange of ideas as expressed in "The American Library Association Bill of Rights," "The American Library Association Intellectual Freedom Statement," "The American Library Association Librarians' Code of Ethics," "The American Library Association Freedom to Read Statement," and the American Film and Video Association's "Freedom to View" statement.

In the selection process, all points of view will be considered without prejudice or censorship.

No materials or resources in the Clark Memorial Library collection will be censored because of personal objection to the author's language, stance, sex, sexual orientation, religion, political philosophy, personal history, personal persuasion, affiliation, or national origin; likewise, materials will not be censored based solely on a personal dislike of or distaste for the subject matter.

Care will be taken to insure that the collection reflects a diversity of viewpoints, especially in areas of scholarly or public disagreement.

Materials and resources selected will be readily available to all Library users.


III. Clientele and Collection Development Decision Priorities

The primary users of the Clark Memorial Library are the students, faculty, and staff at this institution. Collection development decisions and selections will be made first and foremost to provide for the information needs of this group.

In order to facilitate better service for our primary user group, Shawnee State University/Clark Memorial Library has entered into a contractual agreement with OhioLINK, a consortium underwritten by the Ohio Board of Regents and composed of all state college and university libraries in Ohio, the State Library of Ohio, and most private colleges and universities in Ohio. As a member of the OhioLINK system, CML participates in cooperative collection development activities within this consortium.  Students, faculty, staff, and other approved borrowers of OhioLINK member institutions, therefore, make up a secondary clientele. 

Having entered into agreements of reciprocity with other institutions participating in interlibrary loan via OCLC, borrowers represented by other institutions are likewise considered another secondary user group. In a similar manner interlibrary loan requestors using ALA forms are acknowledged as a secondary user group. Collection development decisions are not made with respect to the needs of either of these user groups.

Alumni borrowers, visiting school borrowers, professional colleagues from the local schools, and community members from local or outlying areas constitute yet another secondary user group. As a selective government depository, the Library takes into account the needs of this group when making collection development decisions regarding government documents. Additionally, the Library chooses materials which support the university's community involvement initiatives.


IV. Personnel Roles and Responsibilities

The responsibility for collection development ultimately rests with the Director of the Clark Memorial Library; however, the process by which materials are selected for the collection is a cooperative one shared by librarians, faculty, other staff, and Library users. The Library Director prepares the Library budget, determines the funding formula and process; allocates funds to academic departments and to departments within the Library; and assigns librarians' liaison responsibilities to various departments. The Allocation Formula is included in the appendix of this document.

The Library Director assigns academic department liaison responsibilities to librarians. The liaison serves as a contact person for any questions or issues relating to the Library, expediting the flow of information between the faculty and Library staff and providing faculty with requested information about specific resources. As time allows, liaisons exchange information with faculty about curriculum initiatives, Library needs, new services, and other developments.

Faculty in academic departments are expected to take an active role in selecting library materials, especially in their respective areas of expertise, taking into account the general needs of their students in regards to materials within their discipline as a whole, needs in related disciplines, and needs in interdisciplinary areas. Faculty are expected to evaluate the Library collection, to suggest seminal and/or key materials appropriate to the information and research needs of undergraduates, and to monitor their professional literature for recently published materials appropriate to the university's needs. Departmental Selection Policies specify the parameters within which the departments' purchases should be made. Funds may be used to purchase Library materials in any format, and faculty are encouraged to consider non-print materials and electronic resources. Requests from faculty must be approved by their department chairs before being forwarded to the Library. Every effort will be made to accommodate faculty requests that are within the scope of the Library's Collection Development Policy and that relate to the instructional and educational purposes of SSU, providing that adequate funding is available for acquisition.

As funding permits, the Library will purchase or procure various materials necessary to support and/or assist administrative personnel and other staff in the effective performance of their duties. Requests may be directed to any librarian or communicated electronically via the Clark Memorial Library webpages.

As funding permits, patrons' requests will be honored if they fall within the scope of the Library's Collection Development Policy and support the instructional and educational purposes of the university. Requests may be directed to any librarian or communicated electronically via the Clark Memorial Library webpages.

It is hoped that when funding is restored to adequate levels on campus, a collection development librarian can be added to the Library staff to coordinate selections and assure adequate coverage within critical subject areas.


V. Scope and Boundary of the Collection

The Library collection will reflect the curricular and information needs of the students, faculty, and staff of Shawnee State University. The greatest priority will be given to building a collection to meet the needs of students enrolled in programs currently offered on this campus. Although the Library will not always be able to meet every research need with materials on hand, by relying on OhioLINK borrowing, traditional interlibrary loan mechanisms, and electronic access to various off-site materials, it is hoped that the Library can ultimately provide appropriate information or services to most users. Nonetheless, it must be recognized that the Library cannot be expected to completely satisfy all information needs of all users.

Library materials purchased by the Library or by the Departments with monies allocated from the Library's materials budget must be housed in the Library or be accessible via the Library Webpages.  The Library cooperates in and actively pursues electronic access initiatives to extend resources to remote users across and beyond the SSU campus.

Funds may be used to purchase or contract for Library materials in any format, and faculty are encouraged to consider non-print materials and electronic resources. Requesters should bear in mind that the equipment, software, or applications needed to use a specific piece of software or media may not be available to Library patrons. Additionally, in the same manner that the Library provides print resources for patrons but does not presume to teach patrons how to read those documents, the Library provides technical support of software and existing hardware but does not presume to teach the use of the software or to instruct users in the physical manipulation or intellectual interpretation of the contents.

Serials

Clark Memorial Library actively participates in many electronic full-text initiatives, most especially with OhioLINK, to provide the broadest spectrum of electronic full-text resources for the least money.  The purchase of local serials subscriptions, however, differs from the purchase of other Library materials in several ways:

  • Local serials holdings represent an ongoing commitment of Library funds.  
  • Increases in the costs of annual subscriptions tend to outrun inflation by undeterminable factors.
  • Because periodicals subscriptions are generally begun with the assumption that the title will continue to be purchased in perpetuity, shelf space utilization must be considered more carefully.
  • Because the usefulness of a periodical title will be affected by the run available, retrospective microformat or electronic file purchases must be contemplated when a new title is considered.
  • Secondary subscriptions to appropriate indexes or abstracts or online access to remote research databases may be required to assure the usefulness of the new periodical.
  • Users have demonstrated a preference for online electronic full text; however, access to electronic full text often is often more expensive than traditional hard copy subscriptions, and local contracts do not provide for retrospective access once the subscription/contract has ceased (e.g., CML currently subscribes to the Wall Street Journal in electronic full text, but if we cease the electronic subscription, we will not retain access to the electronic content from the years during which we subscribed.) 

For these reasons, a thoughtful, judicious periodicals selection process investing substantially more deliberation than that of the acquisition of a single monograph is warranted.

Departments may request electronic access, current hard copy, or retrospective (generally microformat) subscriptions. When the Library subscribes to the hard copy of a magazine or journal, we will resolve whether to purchase the microformat of that title.  Some periodicals will be purchased only in microformat.  

The general rule will be to discard retrospective paper holdings. The Library will attempt to maintain at minimum the current year's paper holdings of a magazine or journal. When possible, two to five years of retrospective paper holdings will be maintained. The retention decision will be determined by taking into account such factors as usage, electronic access, and the amount of shelf space available in the Current Periodicals stacks.

If a serial is not available in microformat (as in the Health Sciences' hardback Clinics series) or if there is an over-riding consideration which necessitates retaining retrospective paper issues (as in the need to examine the high-quality, color illustrations printed in the paper version of The Journal of Cell Biology), these items will be bound, classified, and relocated into the circulating stacks.

Cooperative agreements

As a member of the OhioLINK system, it is expected that SSU will participate in cooperative collection development activities with other members of this consortium. The most recent statement on collaborative collection development within OhioLINK is included in the appendix.

Collection Analysis

Faculty are encouraged to analyze and evaluate sections of the SSU collection pertinent to their areas of expertise by utilizing general bibliographic resources such as Books for College Libraries and discipline-specific tools such as Shaw's Information Sources in Physics to determine areas of weakness within the collection. Lists of tools relevant to each department are included within the departmental Selection Policies.

Conspectus

Divisions, categories, and subjects within the Departmental Selection Policies have been amended to conform to the WLN Conspectus (which OhioLINK purchased for cooperative collection development initiatives.) As specific subject areas are evaluated, SSU and OhioLINK information will be shared with the departments responsible for sections analyzed.


VI.  Selection Criteria

Departmental Selection Policies

Each Departmental Selection Policy is based upon an analysis of the degrees offered, GEP requirements, coursework required by other departments, and the number and level of courses offered by that department. Each policy specifies guidelines for languages, formats, chronological periods, geographic areas, exclusions, and area resources. Appropriate WLN assessment printouts are also included in the Departmental Selection Policies. The printouts at minimum indicate assessment comments, categories by LC number, and goal levels for collecting. These policies will be updated regularly to reflect new programs and courses added to the SSU Catalog.

Selectors should be familiar with and selections should be appropriate to the parameters specified in their departmental selection policy. The selection aids included in the departmental selection policies are suggested resources; however, the listing is not comprehensive. Requestors should additionally seek out and rely on resources such as the following when selecting materials.

Specialized bibliographies:

  • Annual subject compilations, e.g., Library of Congress' annual Books for Children recommendations
  • Monograph sources, e.g., Guide to Reference Books, American Reference Books Annual, and Books for College Libraries
  • Bibliographies published by or under the auspices of academic associations, e.g., Library Recommendations for Undergraduate Mathematics from the Mathematical Association of America
  • Bestseller lists, e.g., The New York Times Book Review rankings of bestsellers
  • Compilations in periodicals, e.g., the annual best reference sources article in American Libraries

Reviews in such periodicals as:

  • Choice
  • Library Journal
  • New York Review of Books
  • New York Times Book Review
  • Science Books and Films
  • Scholarly journals

General selection criteria to be considered should include the following:

  • Quality of content
  • Fulfillment of academic curricular need/Appropriateness to academic needs per course offerings
  • Lasting value of the content
  • Intellectual Suitability/Appropriateness of the level of treatment of the subject
  • Strength of present holdings in the same or similar subject area/Completeness of holdings as determined by standard bibliographies and other sources
  • Suitability of format to content
  • Reviews
  • Authoritativeness or credibility
  • Reputation of publisher
  • Accuracy
  • Clarity
  • Depth/Scope of coverage
  • Need for supplementary materials in subject areas of strong student interest or of a contemporary nature
  • Study of use patterns or statistics showing areas of greatest demand or of collection weakness
  • Physical considerations such as binding, format, or cost
  • Conservation/Preservation issues such as acidity and the presence of mold/mildew
  • OhioLINK holdings, especially when cost is high and potential use is low

Serials selection criteria to be considered should include the following:

  • Support of present academic curriculum
  • Strength of the existing collection
  • Present use of this or other periodicals in this subject area
  • Projected future use
  • Cost, rate of anticipated increase, and continuing availability of funding
  • Reputation of journal
  • Reviews in monographs or other journals, e.g., Magazines for Libraries and the journal reviews published in the fall in Nature.
  • Inclusion in prominent abstracting and indexing sources
  • If not owned, number of recent interlibrary loan requests for articles from this serial

Non-print media selection criteria should include the following:

  • Technical quality of production:
  • color
  • sound
  • continuity
  • editing
  • Appropriateness of the audiovisual format to the subject matter
  • Compliance with copyright provisions

Selectors should take advantage of preview or demonstration opportunities before purchasing electronic access or audiovisual, multimedia, or computer software.

Replacement criteria for lost books or irreparably damaged materials are the same as for new purchases. Standard practice is to choose current publications; however, retrospective requests will be honored if the item can be located. Requestors should note that OP (out of print) works can be extremely expensive.


VII. Resource Sharing

In order to provide access to information and materials which are beyond the scope of or otherwise unavailable in this collection, Clark Memorial Library will participate in resource sharing programs.

Patrons will be referred initially to OhioLINK, a consortium of all state college and university libraries and several private college and university libraries in Ohio. Via OhioLINK, SSU users can not only access electronic full text or view graphics and videos, but they can also borrow circulating materials directly from the collections of 83 other member libraries and have requested materials delivered to SSU. 

Items that do not circulate on OhioLINK and materials identified through other sources (e.g., bibliographies, professional networking, broadcast media) which are not available through OhioLINK will be requested through interlibrary loan. 


VIII. Archives

Clark Memorial Library maintains a limited archival collection of university documents and paraphernalia.

At this time, no systematic effort is made to collect comprehensively or to catalog all materials placed in archives.

The Vernal G. Riffe, Jr., Archives located adjacent to the Library proper is administered by the Office of Development and Community Relations.


IX. Collection Review and Deselection Policy

Collection review is an important aspect of collection development. The collection is continually monitored for worn, outdated, or unnecessary materials.

Items which are physically damaged, deteriorated, or embrittled must be repaired, replaced, or withdrawn. Materials which are no longer relevant to the university's programs or which are redundant in the collection are also candidates for deselection.

Withdrawal of irreparable, outdated, and unnecessary materials increases the convenience of the user, allows for a higher proportion of immediately useful materials, allows library staff to work more efficiently in maintaining good shelf order, and increases the availability of shelf space for useful items.

Individual sections of the collection should be periodically reviewed by faculty whose academic specialty or background facilitates expert judgment in those subject areas. Additionally, faculty are encouraged to identify and report outdated materials that they desire be removed from the collection.

Factors to be considered in weeding include:

  • Relevance of the item to the university's current curriculum or to its community initiatives
  • Number of copies needed
  • User demand/circulation record/lack of use
  • Currency/Obsolescence:
  • Interest in superceded or revised editions
  • Value of variant editions
  • Level of currency or interest in retrospective holdings
  • Length of serial backruns
  • Physical condition of material:
  • Acid damaged, aged, brittle materials
  • Moldy, mildewed materials
  • Torn or missing pages/pieces
  • Loose or broken bindings/pieces
  • Damage from contact with fluids or other substances
  • Conservation and preservation concerns:
  • Restoration potential
  • Archival value
  • Availability of replacement
  • Lack of intrinsic merit and/or lack of reference/historical/critical value

X. Gifts

Gifts are encouraged, with the understanding that the library will decide on the disposition of the items which have been given and that the library may add them to the collection at its discretion or dispose of gift items by [selling?], exchanging, donating, or discarding them. As a general rule, gift items will be added to the collection based on the same criteria as purchased materials.

The Library will acknowledge in writing the receipt of gifts; however, the Library assumes no responsibility for appraisal of gifts. The appraisal of a gift for tax purposes is the responsibility of the donor, and the cost of the appraisal, if any, should be borne by the donor.

As a rule the Library does not accept gifts under restricted conditions. In the case of monetary gifts, however, the donor may designate the use of those funds for specific collections or subject areas.


XI. Reconsideration of Challenged Materials

An individual or group who objects to the inclusion of a particular item in the Library's collection may request reconsideration of the inclusion of that item by filling out a Request for Reconsideration. The Library Director will reply in writing to the individual or group who disagree with the inclusion of the item in the collection. If the individual or group should not agree with the Director's response, the Library Director will refer the reconsideration request to the Library Advisory Committee. The Library Advisory Committee will respond in writing to the individual or group who object to the inclusion of the item in the collection.

A copy of the Request for Reconsideration is in the Appendix of this document.


XII. Conservation and Preservation Plan

Deterioration of Paper Products

The Library staff monitors the collection for damaged or deteriorating materials and, when possible, repairs items of continuing usefulness. When damaged or deteriorating materials are irreparable, or when moldy or mildewed items are discovered, they are normally removed from the collection. However, when preservation of content is more important that the integrity of the physical format, these materials may be placed in appropriate containers and shelved in the Archives collection.

Security System

The Library utilizes the 3M Tattletape System to guard against theft during the hours the Library is open. All emergency exits have audible alarms which alert staff that an unauthorized exit is being attempted. Because the windows are immobile, no possibility exists for throwing otherwise removing materials through open windows.

When the building is closed to the public, an intruder alarm system is activated.

University security officers include the Library in their campus patrol.

HVAC

The Library strives to maintain the physical integrity of materials in the collections through conservation measures such as temperature, humidity, and dust control accomplished via an efficient HVAC system. The desired HVAC standard is to maintain 85% of the time a temperature between 68 and 76 degrees Fahrenheit and a humidity level of 45 to 55%.

Lighting

Artificial lighting in the Library is fluorescent. The fixtures and lamps are all of recent vintage; therefore, no fire or toxic risk due to aging or defective ballasts is expected.

On the east side of the building, blinds are used to protect the interior and contents from ultraviolet radiation. There are no windows on the south or west except for the central staircase; no library materials are stored near that area. The skylight is constructed of opaque glass.

Pests

Preventive pest extermination is routinely requested.

Fire Prevention, Detection, and Suppression

A state-of-the-art smoke and fire detection system was installed when the Library was constructed in 1991. When the detection system is set off, a spoken evacuation message directs users to exit the building, a multi-frequency siren sounds, and strobe and red lights flash. The alarm rings automatically into the SSU Facilities Office and the Portsmouth Fire Department. A heat sensitive dry pipe sprinkler system is also included in the building's operating systems.

Fire extinguishers are located on every level beside each stairway, and additional extinguishers are adjacent on inside office areas. The university conducted a fire extinguisher training session during the 1992-93 academic year.

The Physical Facilities Department is responsible for routine maintenance and periodic inspection of these systems.

Smoking is prohibited in all areas of the Library.

Staff exercise vigilance in making sure that all heat-producing appliances are turned off when not in use.

Natural Disasters

Included in the Shawnee State University Building Coordinators Manual are the procedures established for emergency actions during tornadoes, snowstorms, and other potentially destructive weather. A weather radio is kept at Circulation and monitored during bad weather.

Although SSU is not located in the part of Ohio which is most likely to suffer tornadoes, in 1967 a tornado devastated a neighborhood, killing 7 people in Wheelersburg, 7 miles east of Portsmouth. While the SSU Library is constructed to withstand high winds, it is unlikely that it could survive cyclonic winds unscathed. Window damage would most likely result, and materials within could likely be damaged if they were blown off the shelves and/or exposed to moisture.

On average the Portsmouth area receives about 25 inches of snow and about 42 inches of precipitation equivalent to rainfall per year. Extreme weather is not uncommon, however. For instance, during the winter of 1994, a single storm dumped 25-30 inches of snow on the city. Because the Library has a flat roof, staff must be vigilant to monitor leaks on Level Three during and after heavy snowfall and heavy downpours.

Although the Clark Memorial Library is on the floodplain of the Ohio River, the floodwall which protects the city is higher than the water level during the 1937 flood, the highest recorded level, and the Army Corp of Engineers estimates that if a flood of the same volume as the 1937 Flood occurred today, the crest would be 10 feet lower at Portsmouth due to flood control projects which have been constructed in the intervening years. Nonetheless, Level One of the Library may be susceptible to standing water if the ground were saturated and/or if the drains were not able to handle the runoff of ground water around the central staircase and the delivery dock.

Although Portsmouth is approximately 400 miles from the New Madris fault, geologists theorize that the shock waves from a major earthquake there could cause major damage in all the cities along the Ohio Valley. Multi-story structures built on the floodplain may be particularly vulnerable.

University Maintenance and Custodial employees are responsible for controlling and containing potential damage to library materials. Library staff are responsible for decisions regarding materials damaged by the elements.

In order to protect materials from damage, both Facilities and Library employees will consider such measures as covering stacks with plastic sheeting, removing materials from bottom rows of shelving units, and relocating materials to safer areas. More drastic prevention measures will be considered as the need arises.

Emergency Recovery

Shawnee State University insures the Library and its contents. In 1993 the building was valued at $6,284.000 and insured for full replacement value. The furnishings in the facility were valued at $6,284,000 and insured for full replacement value. The print and non-print collections were valued at $5,104,344 for books and $219,618 for microfilm, etc. and insured for full replacement value. All categories are subject to the $10,000 deductible per claim.

As the Library hold few unique or irreplaceable materials and insurance on the facility, furnishings, and collection is adequate to rebuild and replenish the facility, it is unlikely that the Library would engage in heroic salvage measures such as removing the damaged items to a freezer facility, vacuum freeze-drying, or desiccant drying of water-saturated materials. Immediate attention would be given instead to venting the building, removing waste, disinfecting contaminated areas, and securing appropriate repairs to the facility.


XIII. Copyright Policy

Clark Memorial Library shall abide by and comply with copyright regulations as set forth in Title 17 of the U.S. Code. Materials which violate the statute will neither be accepted by Clark Memorial Library temporarily nor added to the collection permanently. Clark Memorial Library will neither engage in nor assist others in any action which violates the current copyright provisions.

Photocopying

In accordance with Title 17 U.S. Code Section 108, a sign displaying the following messages (as specified in 37 CFR Section 201.14 (b) and (c)) will be posted at public access photocopiers:

NOTICE

WARNING CONCERNING COPYRIGHT RESTRICTIONS

The Copyright Law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material.

Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy or other reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction is not to be "used for any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research." If a user makes a request for, or later uses, a photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of "fair use," that user may be liable for copyright infringement.

This institution reserves the right to refuse to accept a copying order if, in its judgment, fulfillment of the order would involve violation of copyright law.

Additionally, the following will also be posted near public access photocopiers:

NOTICE:

The Copyright Law of the United States (Title 17 U.S. Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material.

The person using this equipment is liable for any infringement.

Computer Software

In accordance with Title 17 U.S. Code Section 109 paragraph (b) (2) (A), all computer software will display the following message (37 CFR Section 201.24 (b)) affixed to the packaging in the prescribed manner (37 CRF Section 201.24 (c)):

NOTICE:

Warning of Copyright Restrictions

The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the reproduction, distribution, adaptation, public performance, and public display of copyrighted material.

Under certain conditions of the law, nonprofit libraries are authorized to lend, lease, or rent copies of computer programs to patrons on a nonprofit basis and for nonprofit purposes. Any person who makes an unauthorized copy or adaptation of the computer program, or redistributes the loan copy, or publicly performs or displays the computer program, except as permitted by Title 17 of the United States Code, may be liable for copyright infringement.

This institution reserves the right to refuse to fulfill a loan request if, in its judgment, fulfillment of the request would lead to violation of the copyright law.

Shawnee State will reserve the right to lend lawfully made copies of computer programs as granted in Title 17 U.S. Code Section 109 (b)(2)(A-B) and to make archival copies of computer programs as granted in Title 17 U.S. Code Section 117.

Reproduction of Audiovisual Materials

Media Services will keep on hand and make continuously available to users a pamphlet detailing the rights and responsibilities of educators and others in regard to copyright.


XIV. Policy Review

The collection development policy will be evaluated at regular intervals and amended as necessary to reflect changing user needs, university priorities, and budgetary considerations.


REFERENCE COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT POLICY

The Reference Collection supports the Reference and information needs of the University as an academic institution whose mission "prepares students for the changing needs of business, industry, education, and society through its diversified degree programs." The Reference Collection also supports the University's community involvement initiative: "To enrich the lives of the community, the University provides opportunities for continuing personal and professional development, intellectual discovery, and appreciation for the creative and performing arts."

I. Scope of the Reference Collection

A. The core of the Reference Collection will include basic general information and subject specific materials selected according to the University's curricular needs.
B. The Reference Collection will be supplemented by materials which support broader interests of the university community or which treat subjects in which the University fosters community involvement.
C. All Reference materials which relate to SSU's academic programs or support SSU's institutional objectives, (regardless of subject, chronological period, geographical area treated, format, or medium) may be considered for inclusion. Primary consideration will be given to those items which best satisfy students' academic Reference and information needs.
D. Materials selected by academic departments will be placed in the Reference Collection if, in the Reference Librarians' judgment, they better serve the University in that collection. Conversely, Reference titles selected by academic departments may be placed in the general collection if they do not meet the criteria of the SSU Reference Collection.

II. Types of Reference Tools

Types of reference tools will include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • dictionaries
  • encyclopedias
  • surveys
  • handbooks
  • directories
  • bibliographies
  • atlases
  • manuals
  • indexes
  • abstracts

III. Currency of the Reference Collection

A. The Reference collection should be up-to-date in order to provide accurate, current, and reliable information. Titles held in Reference should generally be the most recent edition. Key works will be placed on standing order. Specific replacement schedules should be in place for exceptions to this rule, e.g., general encyclopedias which issue a "new edition" annually will be replaced every third year.
B. Superceded editions will generally be removed from the Reference Collection when updated works are purchased. Superceded works may be relocated to the circulating collection if the information in them is neither obsolete nor likely to be misleading to users or if they are have retrospective or historical value. Superceded editions should be reviewed for relocation to the circulating collection or for deselection if Reference chooses not to purchase the latest edition.

IV. Selection Criteria

In addition to the selection criteria specified in the SSU Collection Development Policy, the following factors should be considered for inclusion in Reference:

  • Key or standard title in Reference
  • "Raw data" of the field, such as statistical tables
  • Narrow or broad focus of the work
  • Compositional style or format of compilation
  • Bibliographical or other types of references to other resources
  • Acceptable reviews in standard Reference tools such as ARBA, Choice, Sheehy/Balay, RQ, RSR, College & Research Libraries, CRL News, etc.
  • Potential use in Reference
  • Relation of the title to the general collection
  • Physical space available in Reference
  • For ongoing series, the completeness of present holdings

V. Size of Reference Collection

A. A small, well-chosen collection of materials which can be easily accessed will best meet the needs of the SSU community.  
B. Physical space and changes in curriculum will be considered when determining optimal collection limits.

C. The collection will be weeded on an ongoing basis. The Reference staff should complete an annual inventory of the Reference collection.


OhioLINK Cooperative Information Resources Management Committee (CIRM) "Statement of Assumptions & Objectives for Cooperative Collection Development" [6/10/93]                                                                                        

As academic programs develop in response to new technological, economic, social, and intellectual priorities, libraries are required to respond to ever-expanding demands for information resources. In parallel, it is increasingly difficult to maintain support of existing academic programs in the state. The costs of intellectual resources are increasing at a much higher rate than are library budgets; for example, OhioLINK libraries saw price increases of 12% or more between fiscal 92 and fiscal 93 while library budgets decreased an average of 18%. This is not a new phenomenon: Since 1988, Ohio's state-assisted universities have been forced to cancel approximately 9,214 serials subscriptions ($2,097,00). The tactic of canceling serials subscriptions allows libraries to keep pace with inflation, but it does not allow them to respond to new and expanding needs nor to maintain purchasing power for support of existing programs. It also results in less access to library scholarly materials and, consequently, impacts negatively on teaching, research and grant funding, and institutional service programs. Through cooperative collection management initiatives, OhioLINK libraries will be better able to meet demands for expanded access to a broader range of information resources and still to maintain support of existing programs.

ASSUMPTIONS:

1. Cooperative collection management will increase access to information resources for OhioLINK member institutions and their constituents. More effective access to information can be achieved through joint efforts.
2. There is a fundamental shift from ownership to access and ownership. Cost of intellectual resources (whether purchased or accessed) will continue to increase.

3. Information resources are expanding exponentially both in number and in kind.

4. Increasing the breadth of information access through OhioLINK will allow member institutions to increase depth of information in support of local institutional programs as well as programs across the state.

5. Document delivery (both electronic and physical) is a key element to the success of cooperative collection development efforts.

6. In order to carry out necessary collection and use analyses, OhioLINK must have adequate statistical tools. Only in this way will OhioLINK be able to adequately identify related and complementary collections in relation to use. A major assumption is that collection and use data will be available, as well as appropriate statistical analysis tools.

OBJECTIVES:

1. Maximize limited fiscal resources statewide. Expand intellectual resources by cooperative measure.
2. Enhance access to expand intellectual resources for all OhioLINK constituents.
3. Develop models for analyzing collections and use in order to reduce unnecessary duplication while maintaining core resources at each OhioLINK campus.


COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT FOR GOVERNMENT DOCUMENTS

Selection Policy

The Clark Memorial Library is a Selective Depository. The primary emphasis in collection development is support for an undergraduate academic program. Additionally, as a depository, the library has an obligation to be responsive to the needs of the surrounding community.

The excellent cooperation of the Regional Depository at the State Library of Ohio should be considered in making collection development decisions.

Recommendations will be considered from the departments, public library, and other interested parties, but final selection will be accomplished by the Associate Director for Public Services with the advice of the professional staff and approval of the Library Director:

  1. Relevance to the local patron.
  2. Compatibility with the library's total collection.
  3. Degree of technicality.
  4. Potential frequency of use.
  5. Amount of shelf space that will be required to house the material.
  6. Format of document.

At the current time, items described as being "catch-all classes", highly technical, or consuming a considerable volume of paper are selected only when they represent a considerable contribution to the academic program or the community which could not be met with individual requests for loans from the Regional Depository.

Weeding Policy

Shawnee State as a small undergraduate institution has neither the mission nor the space to justify the maintenance of complete retrospective collections of the documents received under the depository library program. The library closely follow the guidelines for the weeding and discarding of depository documents as outlined in the "Instructions to Depository Libraries" manual. Efforts must be made to weed according to the schedule suggested by the regional. However backlogs caused by late publication of Needs and Offers may affect this schedule. In addition to following depository instructions, the additional guidelines for the weeding of Documents as well as other library materials are:

  1. Lack of relevance to the local patron.
  2. Incompatibility with the library's total collection.
  3. Ephemeral material, not of significant historical nature.
  4. Damaged materials which are beyond repair.
  5. Materials for which special equipment is required but is no longer available.
  6. Materials of minimal local value which consume considerable shelf space.
  7. Short incomplete runs of materials which might be of value to other area depositories.
  8. Duplicate items.
  9. Other materials as appropriate with the advice of the Library director, the professional staff and concerned faculty.

NOTE: Documents having any of these characteristics are potential candidates for the weeding program. Before any document is included in the weeding program, factors of historical significance, unique value, and other possible values shall be considered.

Bindery Policy

Documents will be bound according to the policy relating to books and periodicals housed in the library's other collections.

Lost Documents

Lost or damaged documents which fall under the 5 year retention guideline are replaced if still available. Lost or damaged documents which are past the 5 year retention guideline are replaced only if the document is still considered to be of value to the collection. (See above Weeding Policy for retention guidelines.)

Inter-Library Cooperation

The Clark Memorial Library cooperates with the State Library of Ohio and other depository libraries in Southwestern Ohio to share resources for the good of their users. Telefacsimile devices are used for timely document delivery.

References are verified through the OhioLINK Central Catalog.


Curriculum Materials Collection Development Statement*

I. Introduction

During most of the 20th Century, economic conditions and the state of civilization dictated that classroom learning be accomplished via textbook and workbook, paper and pencil, lecture and recital. The occasional inclusion of an audiovisual presentation in the classroom was a special event, and the opportunity for students to gain hands-on experience with realia often was confined to young children in kindergarten and primary school and to high schoolers in academic track courses which included laboratory experiences. In general, however, students whose learning capabilities demanded more than the rote/written recital of text or of a teacher's lecture, recorded during passive, seated observation, were untutored by the educational system and dropped from its ranks, frustrated and frequently lacking in intellectual skills needed for financial and social stability.

Today, in support of a curriculum informed by research, emphasizing the possibilities of human intelligence with such initiatives as the development of critical thinking skills, learning to learn, cultural literacy, competency, and mastery learning, a vast array of teaching tools are available for teachers to utilize in educating students with disparate learning styles. Teachers today have the potential to educate the young people of our country, each according to her or his own need, as never before in our history. In this setting, a collection of curriculum materials takes on great significance in the preparation of teacher candidates. Teacher candidates are in a "window of opportunity" to be exposed to the variety of instruments available to the educator. This Teacher Education program may provide their only exposure to unique resources; if preservice teachers remain ignorant of these possibilities, an untold number of children may be stunted intellectually and emotionally.

To the managers of the CMC and to the education faculty drawing on the resources of the collection of curriculum materials in these years of "shrinking budgets and skyrocketing inflation," judicious selection becomes imperative to insure a quality collection which supports the Teacher Education program. As the production of materials in varying formats increases, collection development strategies must be employed to assure that  teacher candidates have the opportunity to become acquainted with a sampling of all available resources.

*Approved 1/17/1991 by the Curriculum Materials Center Advisory Group; amended 1995 after internal reorganization within the Library; revised Jan. 1998; amended 2001 after internal reorganization within the Library.  This policy conforms to the prescription suggested in Curriculum Materials Center Collection Development Policy  by the Collection Management Subcommittee, Problems of Access and Control of Educational Materials/Curriculum Materials Joint Committee, Educational and Behavioral Science Section, Association of College and Research Libraries, American Library Association (Chicago: ALA, 1984.)  See "Guidelines for Curriculum Materials Centers" for ACRL recommendations regarding the operation of the CMC (link added 2/27/2003). 

II. Objectives of the Collection

Materials selected will support the Teacher Education program at Shawnee State University and will include both educational materials for children from early childhood through young adult and educational materials for teachers and other care-givers who work with children in various early childhood, school, and school-related settings. 

Emphasis will be on materials which have immediate P-12 classroom application.  Although the CMC will also include materials concerned with the teaching methods and classroom management, for the most part, materials dealing with the theory of teaching and with educational research will be placed in the general collection.

In reiteration of Section II of the Clark Memorial Library Collection Development Policy, which asserts the Library's stance on Intellectual Freedom, and in support of the National Council of Teachers of English "Students' Right to Read" statement, the CMC will not exclude materials from the curriculum materials collection based upon an individual's personal objection to the subject matter, content, mode of presentation, etc.

III. Clientele to be Served

Although the service population of the CMC is the same as that of the rest of the library, Teacher candidates and DTE faculty are expected to be the most frequent users of curriculum materials.  Curriculum materials may serve the needs of local educators and of other OhioLINK users, but this use of materials by those groups will be not be a consideration in adding or deselecting materials in this collection.  

Even though the CMC contains juvenile programming materials, it is not intended that children should directly use the facility or the collection. Children entering the CMC should be accompanied by an adult.

IV. Personnel Roles and Responsibilities in the CMC

Librarians, support staff, student employees, and Office of Educational Technology personnel are directly or indirectly involved with the development, maintenance, and operation of the CMC.

A. A Library employee is directly responsible for the staffing, maintenance, and operation of the CMC and Graphics Lab.  The library liaison to the Education Department works with Education faculty to develop the CMC collection. A library employee liaises with the Teacher Education faculty regarding the maintenance of the Graphic Lab operations and the training of the staff to assist users. Allocation of resources in such areas as staff, facilities, equipment, and funding necessary to assure effective and efficient functioning of the CMC rests with the library administration.
B. Although administrative and fiscal responsibility for the operation of the CMC remains with the library, the promotion and utilization of the services and collections of the CMC are faculty-driven. Additionally, faculty involvement is crucial in the development of the curriculum materials collection.

C. A Curriculum Materials Center Advisory Group, composed of professional staff from the Library, Media Services, the Teacher Education Department, and faculty from other departments which support the Teacher Education program may be convened to discuss ways in which the CMC can better meet the needs of users.

V. Scope and Boundary of the Collection

The curriculum materials collection provides resources that support the instructional programs of Teacher Education and other departments which participate in the teacher licensing process. It is expected that a larger portion of the materials in the curriculum materials collection will be in non-print (i.e., audiovisual, multimedia, or realia) formats than would be found in other collections within the Clark Memorial Library.

Collection Guidelines

  1. The collection contains resources appropriate for early childhood through secondary education in such subject areas as art, bilingual/multicultural education, classroom management, curriculum development, developmental psychology, foreign languages, handwriting, health, intervention, inclusion, language arts, literature, mathematics, physical education, middle school, music, reading, science, social studies, and spelling.
  2. The primary language of materials in the collection is English.
  3. Although the collection contains older materials, emphasis is on materials published in the last decade. Materials of historical or research value may be retained.
  4. Educational methods and approaches used across the United States are emphasized in the CMC collection. Materials issued or published by the Ohio Department of Education and by Ohio school districts will be given special attention. Materials from other states and countries are selectively collected.

Collection Formats

  1. Textbooks in all curricular subjects, grades P-12, may be selected. Special attention will be given to acquiring examples of texts adopted by local schools; other exemplary texts are collected selectively.  Older texts may be kept for research value. College level texts are not added to the collection unless they deal with teaching methods or have specific P-12 applications.
  2. P-12 curriculum guides from the state, regional, and national levels are collected selectively. Special attention will be given to acquiring curriculum guides from local districts. Guides may be in either hard copy or electronic full text.
  3. Juvenile literature will be collected. An attempt will be made to comprehensively collect award winners and notable books for children and young adults. Examples of children's classics; beginning-to-read books; picture books; wordless picture books; folk literature; mythology; modern fantasy; poetry; realistic fiction; historical fiction; informational books; biography; and autobiography will be collected.
  4. Professional materials such as idea and activity books; history and criticism of children's and young adult literature;  teaching methods books; and books which teach candidates how to write behavioral objectives and prepare lesson plans will be collected. Books more suited to post-Baccalaureate studies and those which deal broadly with educational research, theory, or history will generally be located not in the CMC but in the general collection.
  5. Reference tools for children and young people are located in the CMC.  Collegiate reference resources that support the P-12 teaching professions are placed in either CMC Reference or in the Reference Stacks on Level 2 according to the subject matter.  The Reference collections may include such items as children's literature indexes and bibliographies; indexes and reviewing sources of audiovisual media and equipment; children's encyclopedias, dictionaries, and thesauri; and biographical information sources on authors and illustrators of children's literature.
  6. Current issues of children's magazines, teacher's magazines, and periodicals devoted exclusively to reviewing children's literature are shelved in the CMC. Retrospective issues on micro will be housed with the micro collections on Level 2.
  7. Government documents that deal with teaching methods or have immediate classroom applicability will be included in the CMC.
  8. While free materials may help supplement the collection, they may be expensive to locate, catalog, and package. Free materials, especially those from commercial organizations and industry, will be critically reviewed before adding. Materials from professional organizations also will be considered for inclusion only after careful scrutiny.
  9. Audiovisual and multimedia materials for demonstration purposes and to provide resources that students may use in integrating educational technology are included in the CMC.  Examples include CDs, CD-ROMs, charts, pictures, study prints, photographs, slides, cassettes, multimedia kits, videos, simulation games, computer programs, transparencies, manipulatives, models, realia, and educational toys.  Appropriate computer hardware is also located in the CMC and appropriate audiovisual hardware is located in Media Services adjacent to the CMC.
  10. Sample teaching units and student-produced units may also be collected.
  11. Samples of standardized tests may be collected. 
  12. Vendor catalogs, pictures, maps, charts, and posters may be collected as vertical or flat file materials.
  13. New and emerging instructional technologies that impact upon educational practices will be incorporated into the CMC.

VI. Selection Criteria

Selectors of curriculum materials should employ the criteria outlined in Section VI of the Clark Memorial Library Collection Development Policy. Ideally, when selecting curriculum materials, the selector should arrange for first-hand examination of the items to be purchased. Expensive materials, especially, should be previewed before purchase.

The potential use of materials should be estimated on both immediate and long-term bases. Versatile materials, especially those which have potential for use in several subjects and grades, should have priority over materials which are less likely to be widely used. In general, the materials selected should have received favorable reviews in the professional literature of a given subject field or in standard review sources.

The following factors may also be considered by the selector:

  • The cost of the material in relation to the budget and other available material.
  • The degree to which the material meets the curriculum objectives of the Department of Teacher Education.
  • The technical quality of production/manufacturing, of writing/presentation, and/or of format/construction.
  • The strengths and weaknesses of the existing collection in relation to the current needs of the clientele.
  • The scarcity of material on the subject and the demand for material by users.
  • The authoritativeness, reputation, and significance of the author/artist/composer/editor and the publisher/producer/manufacturer.
  • The appropriateness of the level of the content for the intended learner, and, if applicable, the provision for student differences in grade and ability level, interests, achievement, and background.
  • The soundness and timeliness of the material in relation to current trends in education, its relevance to today's world, and its likelihood of premature obsolescence.
  • The ability of the material to provide adequate coverage of the necessary facts and concepts in an organized and clear fashion.
  • The ease of use as opposed to a) intellectually, the necessity for users to receive specialized training or b) physically, an unwieldy size or mass posing awkward manipulation difficulties.
  • Representation/demonstration of various learning and teaching styles.
  • Accuracy and thoroughness of material presented as factual.
  • Aesthetic, artistic, and/or literary quality of creative/imaginative materials.
  • Capacity for fostering self-instruction and/or stimulation of creativity.
  • Multiple ethnic, cultural, racial, religious, social, and sexual characteristics; the variety of economic and geographic orientations, problems, aspirations, attitudes, and ideals presented.
  • The manner in which the material deals with controversial issues and the point of view of the presentation; the fostering of critical reading and/or thinking skills.
  • Multiple sensory involvement; multiple mediums engaging a broadened learning spectrum.
  • The content and the value of the work as a whole and its success in achieving its intended results.

While selection ideally is informed by first-hand examination, selection tools serve as secondary sources and provide information about materials in many formats. The following resources may be considered:

  • Monographic retrospective selection tools such as the following may be used:
    • A to Zoo: Subject Access to Children's Picture Books.  New Providence, N.J. : R.R. Bowker.
    • Children's Catalog. New York: H.W. Wilson.
    • Middle and Junior High School Library Catalog. New York: H.W. Wilson.
    • Senior High School Library Catalog. New York: H.W. Wilson.
    • Adventuring with Books: A Booklist for PreK-Grade 8. Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English. Committee on the Elementary School Booklist.
    • The Elementary School Library Collection: A Guide to Books & Other Media. Williamsport, PA: Bro-Dart Foundation.
    • Guide to Reference Books for School Media Center. Littleton, CO: Libraries Unlimited.
    • Publications of Educators Progress Service, Randolph, WI, i.e., the Educators Guide Series.
    • Books for You: A Reading List for Senior High School Students. Urbana, IL: National Council for Teachers of English.
    • Magazines for Libraries. New York: Bowker.
    • U.S. Government Publications for the School Media Center. Littleton, CO: Libraries Unlimited.
    • Your Reading: A Booklist for Junior High Students. Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English
  • Periodicals devoted to specific facets of education, such as Science Books and Films, Science and Children, or Teaching Children Mathematics, can be used to locate outstanding materials.  Horn Book Magazine and School Library Journal are examples of professional periodicals which can be checked for locating reviews of current outstanding materials for children.  

VII. Gifts

The gift policy and procedures are outlined in Section X of the Clark Memorial Library Collection Development Policy.

Gifts will be added to the CMC collection only if they enhance the quality and usefulness of the collection. Items considered may include earlier and outdated editions of curriculum materials since research may be conducted regarding the development and evolution of these materials. Because of the nature of some curriculum materials, e.g., teaching kits or games, care should be taken upon receipt, and prior to acceptance of the gift, that the materials are complete, and, therefore, most useful to the users of the CMC.

VIII. Collection Review and Deselection